Thursday, 30 September 2010

The Definition of My Daughter's Success

As I read articles about talented college graduates unable to find work because the US job growth rate is not keeping pace with the college graduation rate, I speculate about the best way to define success for my 17 year old daughter.

Is it a high paying job as doctor, lawyer, or stockbroker?

Is it fame resulting from some remarkable talent?

Is it her pursuit of one of my dreams  - being a naturalist, an environmental engineer, or outdoor educator?

Is it successfully competing with some local, regional, or national peers to be the best at something?

Should I compare her to the athletes, musicians, performers, artists, and academicians in her school and ask her to be as good or better than they are?

All such measures of success are perilous.

How many doctors, lawyers, or hedge fund traders have you met that are satisfied with their lives and look forward to the challenges of their career every day?

How well does fame really serve anyone?  Just ask Paris Hilton, Lindsey Lohan, or Michael Jackson's family.

Imprinting unfilled parental dreams on children is likely not sustainable.  Children need to find and pursue their own passions.

Competitive spirit is a great thing to have, except when it leads to a winning at all costs mentality, sacrificing ethics along the way.   Just ask the steroid using baseball players.

Comparing your children to others is an insult to the individuality of your children.   When I think back on my own childhood, my peers who could have been held up as ideal comparisons did not end up with happy or fulfilling lives.   Some peaked in High School.    A journey of continuous optimism and life improvement, striving to be the best you can be on your own terms, seems like a better course than making comparisons to other people along the way.

The bottom line - asking my daughter to fulfill my expectations, follow in my footsteps. or live up to standards I set does not respect her ability to  choose and pursue her own dreams.

Thus, my definition of success for my daughter is simple.  It's not related  to grades, talent, dollars, or fame.  

If she can develop a sense of self-worth, pursing a path designed by her that fuels her self-esteem, then she will be successful.

The world of the 21st century is a complex place.   Traditional measures of success - a job, a house, a family - are not necessarily the obvious goals that should be pursued by the next generation.  

As she enters the college of her choice (it's up to her), and pursues the educational path of her choice, following her passions and crafting her own life path, I only ask one thing.

If 5 years from now she can say "I feel good about me", then she (and I as a parent) have been successful.

Wednesday, 29 September 2010

A Milestone for Vocabulary Resources

The Vocabulary Task Force of the HIT Standards Committee is hard at work specifying the vocabularies and codesets that should be publicly available to accelerate certification and meaningful use efforts.

Today, Kaiser Permanente announced the donation of its Convergent Medical Terminology (CMT) to the International Healthcare Terminology Standards Development Organisation (IHTSDO©) for U.S. distribution through the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) so that all health care providers—large and small—can benefit from the translation-enabling technology.

This donation makes the results of years of work at Kaiser Permanente available to help U.S. health professionals and hospitals achieve key meaningful use standards set forth by the Office of the National Coordinator of Health IT and the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services.

The donation includes:

1.  Over 75,000 extensions to existing vocabularies (new concepts, natural language descriptions for clinicians and patient friendly terms)

2.  Derivative works (crossmaps of vocabularies to each other)

3.  Toolkits for collaborative editing

In addition to the Kaiser donation, below is a guide to other freely available resources, such as crossmaps from SNOMED CT to ICD-9-CM and ICD-10-CM.

The CM versions used in the US (produced by the National Center for Health Statistics, CDC)  are different from the basic ICD-9 and ICD-10 as released by the World Health Organization.  There is a project to map SNOMED CT to the basic ICD-10 that is being undertaken by the International Health Terminology Standards Development Organisation (IHTSDO), which is the owner of SNOMED CT.

SNOMED CT to ICD-9-CM  - There are two free mappings from SNOMED CT to ICD-10-CM, a basic "conceptual" mapping which is released with SNOMED CT (free to all US users under the UMLS license) and a draft rule-based mapping for the reimbursement use case.  The rule-based map includes IF-THEN rules for selecting the appropriate ICD-9-CM code for a condition in those cases when a SNOMED CT concept could map to more than one ICD-9-CM entry.  For example, in order to select the appropriate ICD-9-CM code for infertility, you must look elsewhere in the patient's record to determine whether the patient is male or female.  Having received modest feedback on the draft mapping, the next step is to produce a current rule-based map that covers all entries in the SNOMED CT CORE problem list subset, which we hope to complete by early 2011.

SNOMED CT to ICD-10-CM - NLM is currently inserting ICD-10-CM into the UMLS Metathesaurus, which will create the synonymous mappings between SNOMED CT and ICD-10-CM.  When this step has been completed (by November 2010), we will work on a rule-based mapping between the SNOMED CT CORE Problem list subset and ICD-10-CM.  This should become available in later in 2011.

All of the above information refers to mappings of diagnoses and conditions - not procedures.

For completeness, access to DRG and Medicare/Medicaid data resources is described below.

The “GROUPER” program, used by Medicare associates ICD-9-CM codes with specific “diagnosis-related” codes.  These codes, previously called “DRGs” (“diagnosis-related groups”) are now properly called Medicare Severity Diagnosis Related Groups (MS-DRGs).   The GROUPER logic, which was developed and is maintained by 3M/Health Information Systems, is updated annually as part of the regulatory update process required for Medicare Inpatient Prospective Payment System.

The software for the GROUPER is distributed for a fee from NTIS.  The complete documentation of the GROUPER logic/Definitions Manual is distributed for a fee from 3M.

Medicare or Medicaid data is available for research from CMS’s Research Data Assistance Center (“ResDAC”), which is a CMS contractor that provides free assistance to academic, government and non-profit researchers interested in using Medicare and/or Medicaid data for their research. ResDAC is staffed by a consortium of epidemiologists, public health specialists, health services researchers, biostatisticians, and health informatics specialists from the University of Minnesota.  Please see the ResDAC website for more information.

Tuesday, 28 September 2010

Clarifying the Meaningful Use Quality Measures

As the country prepares for meaningful use stage 1, many are studying the functionality of their EHRs, hospital information systems, and data warehouses to ensure they can produce the ambulatory and hospital quality measures.

This has led to many implementation questions.

The ambulatory measures and guidance are detailed on a previous blog.

The hospital quality measures for 2011-2012 are found in pages 303-305 of the Final Rule, available here.

Additional guidance from CMS is available here.

The detailed HITSP documentation detailing the standards for computing numerators and denominators is available here.

The most useful, focused, and streamlined materials are the definitions of the quality measures. These measures are encoded according to the HL7 Health Quality Measures Format. To view them

1. Download the HITSP_Quality_Measures_20100430.zip file.
2. Create a new folder on your hard drive.
3. Extract the entire contents of the HITSP_Quality_Measures_20100430.zip file into the new folder.
4. Open the new folder.
5. Double click on a file to open and read the individual .xml files using your internet browser

For the two Emergency Department (ED) Throughput measures, ED-1/NQF 0495 and ED-2/NQF 0497, the information on the numerators/denominators/exclusions is available here.  To fall into the admitted to the emergency department denominator a patient must do two things:

1)      Initially present at the ED

Then either 2) be subsequently admitted to the inpatient side or 2) receive observation services.

A patient seen in the ED who is neither admitted or receives observation services would not be in the denominator.

Hospitals have varying rules about where they provide what type of observation services and patients could receive observation services without ever going through the ED just like they could be admitted to the hospital without ever going through the ED. It is not CMS' intent to expand into Place of Service (POS) Code 22 (Outpatient Hospital - A portion of a hospital which provides diagnostic, therapeutic (both surgical and non-surgical), and rehabilitation services to sick or injured persons who do not require hospitalization or institutionalization.). This is why CMS had to include the first criteria.

I hope these resources are helpful to you.

Monday, 27 September 2010

Unconscious in the Emergency Department

As State Health Information Exchanges and Federal efforts (NHIN Connect/NHIN Direct) implement the data sharing technology that will enable all providers in the country to achieve Meaningful Use Stage 1, I'm often asked  "but when will this healthcare information exchange technology be able to retrieve all my records from everywhere when I'm lying unconscious in the Emergency Department and cannot give a history?"

Here are my thoughts about the trajectory we're on and how it will lead us to supporting the "Unconscious in the ED" use case.

Meaningful Use Stage 1 is about capturing data electronically in EHRs.  Getting healthcare data in electronic form is foundational to any data exchanges.   By 2011 we should have medication lists, problem lists, allergies, and summaries available from EHRs.

The data exchanges in Stage 1 are simple pushes of data from point A to point B - from provider to public health, from provider to provider, and from provider to pharmacy.   There is no master patient index, no record locator service, and no centralized database containing everyone's lifetime health record.

The Stage 1 data exchanges are the right first step.   Serving as chair for a health information exchange for 12 years, I can tell you that pushing data from point A to point B builds trust and breaks down political barriers to data sharing.   The policy needed to guide  push technology is straightforward, since the parties involved in the exchange are limited - the sender and the receiver.  Consent can be simple.  For a referral, this might be "do you permit me to send your data to a specialist so that your care can be coordinated?"

But how are we going to get to a model that supports the pulling of data by emergency rooms?

There are several engineering approaches.

One is to create a master patient index for a state or region so that the identity of patients seeking care is known.   Once we have a master patient index, we can build a record locator service to keep track of every site the patient visits.   Then, we can build a consent repository so that the patient can control what is shared.  During an emergency department encounter, summaries can be pulled from those sites listed in the record locator service which the patient has agreed to share.

I know that this approach works, because it is what I implemented at the hospitals of CareGroup in 1997 as the focus of my MIT thesis.

However, it does have scalability problems.   Given that there are 500,000 doctors and 5000 acute care hospitals, the engineering complexity to pull data from multiple, disparate sites is significant and it requires that all sites support real time queries 24x7x365, maintaining the necessary security and robustness to enable such interchange.   That's a tall order.

An alternative, that is simpler from an engineering perspective and achievable with the Stage 1 push technologies looks like this.

What if payers, providers, and private vendors offered something called "the electronic medical home"?  The patient needs to pick some hosting option they trust.  Just as Stage 1 of meaningful use supports push transactions from provider to provider, the same transactions could be pushed to the electronic medical home designated by the patient.    This has the added advantage of providing a means to  support the patient engagement provisions of Stage 1 (deliver summaries of ambulatory encounters within 3 business days, deliver inpatient summaries upon request, deliver lifetime health summaries upon request).   If every producer of data (lab, pharmacy, hospital, eligible professional etc) pushed a copy of the data they generated to the electronic medical home chosen by the patient, then the patient could become steward of their lifetime medical record hosted by the trusted agent of their choice.  Medical home data would be complete and constantly updated by data producers.

Patients could store their electronic medical home designation on a card in their wallet or on a medical alert bracelet.   If patients visited the emergency room of a hospital they had registered at previously, the hospital would have a record of the patient's electronic medical home selection since the hospital would be one of the medical home data sources.

Ok, but what if the patient arrives in the Emergency Department, naked and unconscious so there is no electronic medical home designation on their body?   I can tell you that in all my years of practicing emergency medicine, I have never treated a naked and unconscious patient, but let's think about the scenario.

There could be a national or a federated regional database which keeps a record of the designated electronic medical home - an "electronic medical home locator service" that is easy to implement because it only has to point to one place, not to every location which has records about the patient.

When the patient arrives naked and unconscious in the emergency department, assuming someone knows the name/date of birth of the patient, the electronic medical home locator service is queried and once the selection of medical home is known, that one location could be queried to retrieve all of the records.

Finally, just to play out the complete use case to its most absurd, if no one knows the patient identity, then we could suggest the electronic medical home locator service should contain a hash of a fingerprint, so that  a biometric - a scan of the patient's finger - could be used to identify the electronic medical home designation and then retrieve the  lifetime record summary.

Summarizing

1.  In Meaningful Use Phase 1, we implement push transactions by 2011.   Google Health, Microsoft Healthvault, Hospitals, and Payers should create electronic medical home repositories capable of receiving push transactions so that copies of inpatient, outpatient and lifetime summaries can be sent there.   The transport mechanism used to push data to the medical home could be REST, SOAP, or SMTP, just as the NHIN Direct project has suggested.   Ideally electronic medical home providers will issue each patient a Health URL, making it easy for EHRs and  health information exchanges to route data to the correct location.

2.  When an electronic medical home designation is elected, a copy of the designation and a hash of the patient's fingerprint is sent to a regional or national electronic medical home locator service.

3.  When the patient arrives unconscious, the name and date of birth  of the patient is used to query the electronic medical home locator service, retrieve the electronic medical home designation and then retrieve the lifetime record summary.

4.  If the patient is naked and unconscious, a fingerprint scan could be used to retrieve the electronic medical home designation and their records.

5.  All of this is empowered by Stage 1 of Meaningful Use as currently written.   All that needs to happen is that providers, payers and vendors need to offer a place to push transactions on behalf of the patient.  

Some have suggested that we should abandon the NHIN Connect, NHIN Direct, and Stage 1 push exchanges in favor of an engineering optimal solution of creating one large database of all electronic health records in the cloud.

Sometimes the engineering optimal solution is not the social/policy optimal solution.

The idea of creating a voluntary, opt-in electronic medical home supported by many hosts - payers, providers, vendors etc.  is achievable and appealing.

In the US, we are wary of any top down, government mandate.   We  are suspicious of centralizing anything.  Maintaining patient control of healthcare data and letting the market provide multiple hosting options seems like an achievable architecture that builds upon what we have already implemented and the meaningful use regulations already in place.

Friday, 24 September 2010

Cool Technology of the Week

Over the last few weeks, I've been writing about green energy sources and products.

One alternative I've never considered is harnessing the chattiness of teenagers.   It's not yet ready for use in general consumer devices, but the research is fascinating.

Another alternative I've never considered is using the power of dog poop to provide lighting in dog parks.   Here it is in action.

Capturing alternative energy sources  through innovation and creativity - that's cool.

Thursday, 23 September 2010

The Olympic Kayak Experience

During the Summer, I kayak the Charles River each evening using performance and fitness kayaks. Depending on wind and weather conditions I'll chose the Epic 18X (a fast, stable sea kayak optimized for ocean racing), the Epic V10 Sport (a faster, moderately stable surfski) or the Epic V12 (the fastest, less stable surfski).

However, I've not ever tried a K1 racing kayak, considered the boat of elite, highly advanced paddlers that is so unstable, you must keep paddling to keep it upright.

One of our BIDMC IT managers, Tyrone Dell, trained for the 1992 Olympic kayak team and he still paddles his Cleaver K1 from that era. Of interest, the boat was made for John Long, one of the legendary rock climbers of our era and the first person to free climb El Capitan in a day. Ty and John kayaked together in Marina Del Rey during the same years I lived in Southern California. Small world.

Ty generously offered to teach me to paddle his K1.

Last weekend, we drove to Hingham, Massachusetts and launched our boats in the calm seas of the inner harbor.

How'd it go? Here's a YouTube video that illustrates the challenge.

Over the course of two hours, I progressed from 10 feet to a full quarter mile before flipping the kayak into the harbor.

The water was 62 degrees and the winds were calm, so my Hydroskin pants and Kokotat paddle jacket kept me warm during my frequent swimming experiences.

When a K1 flips, you cannot get back into it. You need to swim to shore, kayak in tow, empty it out, then reenter. Ty did a marvelous job of keeping me stable until I could balance on my own and begin paddling.

At this point, I fully understand the challenge of using a K1 - it's remarkably fast, but so tippy that rotation of the hips, shoulders or neck results in a swim. I now know how to balance, how to make slow/smooth strokes, and how to achieve the focus needed to keep the boat afloat.

Next Summer, I'll plan on taking a K1 such as the Volcan from Simon River Sports (available for rental at Charles River Canoe and Kayak) to Walden Pond where the sandy beach, clear water, and lack of vegetation will give me a great training ground. The advantage of mastering a K1 is that any style of kayak feels like a barge by comparison!

Wednesday, 22 September 2010

The SafeRx Awards

Yesterday at the Senate Hart Building in Washington DC, Surescripts announced the E-prescribing leaders in the US. Massachusetts was named #1 in the country. Steve Fox from Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts and I represented the Commonwealth. The 10 states with the highest rates of E-Prescribing are:

1. Massachusetts
2. Michigan
3. Rhode Island
4. Delaware
5. North Carolina
6. Connecticut
7. Pennsylvania
8. Hawaii*
9. Indiana*
10. Florida*
*New to the top 10

Our next challenge in Massachusetts is to implement E-prescribing of controlled substances. We'll pilot the use of biometrics and hard tokens to determine the best approach for two factor authentication in different use cases.

Our secret to maintaining the #1 spot in E-prescribing in the country for 4 years? Payer/provider collaboration and region-wide adoption of tools including educational materials, an E-prescribing gateway, common implementation guides, and broad collaboration with Surescripts.

Girls Generation - Korean